"Are you asking me how it feels to be in love with two people, Spellman?" he asks, perching on the arm of the sofa and looking down at her. "Because, honestly, I don't know. I didn't figure it out until I met you."
Other options:
no subject
"Are you asking me how it feels to be in love with two people, Spellman?" he asks, perching on the arm of the sofa and looking down at her. "Because, honestly, I don't know. I didn't figure it out until I met you."